September 20, 2008

The Credibility of Academic Professors

Professors are made for each other. They live in this world of academia that is sheltered from the real world of supply and demand for everything. They dedicate their life to research and at the same time, spend a bit of time, sharing what they learnt with their reluctant audience : the undergraduates. At times, I feel like i am being force fed information that doesnt really have any significance or any form of relevance to the real world.

Theories, theories and more theories. They rely so much on past information and do all kinds of statistical models that I ever wonder whether they are living in the present. They have dedicated their souls to the past.

Lets take an example here. Now, take a finance professor. He goes on and on and on abt financial theories abt this ARBITRAGE Theory model, this valuation method of a stock, this method of buying an undervalued stock. Looking at technical analysis. Grinding out numbers and doing statistical regression. All is just a bunch of bull la seriously. If you spent so much time analysing a stock and its past information, you will grow old researching.

Just focus on the fundamentals as our great Warren Buffet always champions. A business with a solid management team and solid business concept. Its bound to grow. Share prices are dependent on various factors and trust me, I have come to realise that the stock market is just one super cranky and moody person. However saying that, the stock prices are dependent on the trading patterns of the investors. So once you feed information to the investors, they go abt buying and selling till the appropriate valuation of the stock is reached.

Now back to my assessment of the professors, they go on and on abt finance theories, do they own their own portfolio ? Nope they dont!! So the irony in that is, theories always land u in a educational institution.

When I pay 6000 plus dollars per year for my education, I expect top notch quality education. I expect tutors who are able to provide us with valuable insights in to the working world. I expect tutors who have been experienced in their field. I dont care if you are a PHD holder or an A level failure, you gotta speak from experience. You dont have the right to talk abt entrepreneurship if you are not an entrepreneur yourself. You dont have the right to talk abt marketing if you are not a marketing consultant yourself.

Now, thats why university education is just abt theories if you dont go beyond the classrooms and go for activities. But one thing standing in my way usually, grades are the bread and butter and employers believe that students who dedicate their university to grades are solid employees. So we have to give in to their demands.

Ultimately, I give in to the professors to get the grades regardless of whether i believe in their method of education. In the end, you get the grades but nothing on learning value. Thats the price you gotta pay for a degree in Singapore. They squeeze you dry , real dry. We are the ones paying for the education, yet as customers we are the ones who have to give in to the demands of the professors interests. Professors , I salute you all for your courage to suppress us now. Trust me, I cant wait to unleash my frustration when the time calls for it. For now, lets just give in to them, get the grade, be an all rounded student who can speak, write well and work like a dog. Cheers to this philosophy.

Dreams + Constraints = Reality

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I used to be very intrigued by Chinese martial arts movies. There was the Drunken Fist which after you learned it, you will become invincible. There were also the Tai Chi Fist, the 18 Fists that subdue the Dragon, the inner strength of Nine Suns, and recently the Stephen Chow's Buddha Fist. They all give the audience the idea that there is an skill package out there that once you learned it, you will become invincible.

Well in finance there is no such skill package. Finance is more like present day unarmed combat. The student learns stroke by stroke, understand the rationale behind them, master each stroke as best as he can, and then apply in clever ways during battle. In the same way, finance is full of theories which the student needs to learn systematically, understand, master and in when in his job try to apply in clever ways. Many practitioners actually come back to school because they have run out of "strokes" or tactics to use in their job, hence they come back to learn more theories. Therefore a good finance education is one that teaches as much such theories as possible and going into as deep into these theories as possible. It is only through depth, that innovations and creativity can spawn new theories and tactic.

Compare this to a so called successful practitioner. Firstly you do not know his success is really due to some insights into the "truth" or that he is plain lucky. The fact that more than 50% of fund managers do not beat the market, shows that more of them are plain luck than plain "truth". The other 50% who currently beat the market may also be just plain lucky. Hence in your keenness to learn from the successful practitioner, you may end up:
a) learning nonsense. For example you learn to buy on every full moon day and sell on every new moon day. It worked for him in his 18 years of working experience. But do you want to believe him? More sophisticatedly, he could teach you a proprietary technical analysis method (no different from just looking for full moon and new moon), and teach you the buy signal and sell signal. But do you have the faith that this is the truth and not luck?
b) learning a very narrow perspective. Most success stories are situational. The person may have met with a good starting opportunity, great colleagues to learn from, some particular events that gave them a break through, enjoyed some tips and cheap brokerage deals to lower cost, and some great network in the business world who feed them with sufficient insider scoop. Do they really know about finance? Maybe not. Are they good with the 300 stocks that they never dealt with in their career? Maybe not as well. Can they advise on corporate finance, exchange rates, call options or know how to measure risk? Maybe not. If they were to teach in university classes, they would speak non stop about their war stories. Somehow students get very fascinated by them. But in the end, would you learn a skill that will prepare you for change in the next 40 years of your finance career?
c) learning that learning is not necessary. The most poisonous thing that a practitioner tends to teach, is that learning is not necessary. They would say, "Look, I have found the 'truth'. Just repeat this 'truth' and you will be successful for the rest of your career. There is no need to learn any other things. You do not need a degree, MBA or a PhD." Or they may say, "I am smarter than a MBA or PhD. Their knowledge is useless anyway." Such ideas are very poisonous to education. Firstly they are wrong about their 'truth'. Soon they would be hit by a down period that make them realize all that they thought they know about the market, are not true. Then they have to start learning about the market all over again. And this re-learning, is nothing more than going back to school and re-learn with a more open mind. And as they re-learn with an open mind, they would realize that it is not simple education. The math in the finance world baffles even geniuses in Mathematics. The finance world is up keeping a set of theory that is provable, and empirically testable, as compared to the industry's "I know it is true" attitude. It is because of such rigor in the finance academic, that they produce long surviving theories, which practitioners can fall back on.

As NTU moves towards becoming a research university, there would be more and more high research quality professors. They are the ones in the forefront of knowledge creation -- the knowledge that are provable and testable. If you do not think such people are credible, then I don't know who else you can regard as credible. They are definitely not coaches that won gold medals in Olympics. But they can definitely teach you enough strokes to win the gold medal in Olympics -- they can teach you all the theories you need to become the next Warren Buffet. Warren Buffet is but one way of successful practice. There are other great fund managers out there with other successful ways of practice. Each of them do not have a "18 Fists that subdue the Dragon" invincible skill package. Their successful ways of practice still boil down to stroke by stroke clever execution of theory. And now in your 1st year of finance education, you are learning those theories. Learn from those who create these theories!

Learning is change, and change is painful. Hence education is a very paradoxical service in which the provider tries to change the customer. While the provider can be sensitive as to how to best bring out change in the customer, the provider should not spare the change in the customer. Certain things need to be memorized and at the finger tips of the professional. For example if you go to a doctor, and after he takes the thermometer out of your mouth, you would prefer him to know straight away whether you are having a fever or not, rather than surf the net and wiki what is the normal human's temperature. In the same way, a good finance professional needs to remember many stuff such as time value of money, CAPM, arbitrage tricks, methods for valuing a stock, and some statistical techniques. If he is really good, he can even remember what the usual P/E ratio of various industries is and can thus spot abnormalities without machine help. He can remember the beta ranges in an industry, the typical capital structure, up till some typical call prices of certain stocks.

Are you up to this level yet? Reaching this level is not easy, and our mind would play tricks on us. Our mind would think of excuses to take the easy way out and not learn. One of the most common excuse would be "is it useful at all?" If it is not useful, it would not be taught in all finance education and business schools throughout the world! This is even taught in the orientation of new finance job hires in reputable financial institutions! The reverse question to you instead is: are you good enough to learn and handle it? Are you going to take up the challenge or continue to sit there and think of excuses for yourself? Stop blaming and doubting the credibility of professors! Do you even have 1% of their finance knowledge? If you do not have, what gives you credibility to doubt their credibility! ;)

The sad thing is that as the students become increasingly unwilling to learn, the research university's professors are increasingly unwilling to teach as well. Obviously teaching does not help in their research work. Hence ironically the more they dedicate themselves to teaching the faster they would be fired from the university. Students do not help as well. The more the teacher would like to teach, the more the unwilling students would give very bad feedback to the teacher. Hence this speeds up the firing from the university. Carrying on this logic, the stable state would be professors who teach less and less, and students learn less and less -- both are happy. But in actual fact, this is destroying education itself. You are actually getting less from your increasing school fees! To see how much each subject has been watered down throughout the years, just compare the current course outline with those like 5 years ago or 10 years ago. Students back then have less A's in their A level, but they actually learned more and complained less in their university education. Looking forward, say 5 years later, syllabus will probably be cut even further to say 50% of what is covered currently. Is this the kind of education that you want?

Hence students should save their own education by insisting on learning more instead of learning less. Ask for a tough education that has no exemption! Don’t ask for one that removes subjects simply because the subjects are too difficult for the student. In fact ask for one that adds difficult and worthy subjects! I mean why learn easy stuff in the university that you could have learned on your own?

Therefore stop doubting and start learning. A positive attitude would help too. Aim to understand all that is thrown to you. If you cannot understand, then post it as a challenge to yourself that you must become clever enough to understand. Confront the challenge and brave the challenge. If you do this, you will emerge a more knowledgeable person, cleverer person, a more confident person, a more disciplined person, and most importantly a more positive person. Then I would truly say that you have fully reaped the fruits of education. :)

manish09 said...

Thanks for your very comprehensive analysis of my entry and your very calculated insights in to the world of education, finance and ultimately learning as a life skill to back up your points.

Now, I am not doubting for one second the importance of a university degree and the knowledge that i can reap from it. I am just in doubt in some of the unnecessary elements that are force fed onto us. Yes, agreed that various theories such as CAPM and time value of money are timeless. My only concern is yes, the profs make sense but wouldnt it be much credible if they could back it up with their own analysis of their own portfolio and background rather than just stick to rudimentary and basic analysis.

Yes. I have never doubted learning. I have never ever discounted the importance of knowledge and learning. I really appreciate your profound use of examples to back up your analysis.

And i completely agree with ur stand on learning as stated below

"Therefore stop doubting and start learning. A positive attitude would help too. Aim to understand all that is thrown to you. If you cannot understand, then post it as a challenge to yourself that you must become clever enough to understand. Confront the challenge and brave the challenge. "

Cheers, have a great weekend.

Anonymous said...

Haha my previous comment was indeed a little too extreme ;) Sorry about that. Indeed there are no lacking of profs who are either too theoretical (with no war stories) or too practical (with only war stories and no theories). It is difficult to meet a prof that can actually balance both. This is not unique to NTU. Even ivy-league schools in US face the same problem. Their profs may publish a break-through paper in a top journal, with all the following cheers and publicity about it. But if you ask them how to apply it, you will quickly realize from their answers that they had no idea as well ;) They will only start telling you what their paper is not about :P

Nonetheless, now is the time for you to cramp as much theory as you can into your head, for use in the 40 years of career ahead. Sometimes it is not the theory itself that is important, but the twists and turns and somersaults that the theory forces you through that is important.

For example why should any one do such a useless activity as running 6 laps around a stadium track? In real applications, you would never run in circles. Either you are trying to get somewhere, that's why you run, or you are not trying to get somewhere, and hence you do not need to run. Hence why practice running in circles? Well the answer is because you want to get the indirect benefits from running -- a better health and stamina.

Similarly the twists and turns and somersaults in your head may have no real world applications, but by going through them in your head, certain neuron pathways become developed. The next time you need to do a similar twist in your head for whatever innovative real world application, you would be able to do so faster, better and more accurately.

Therefore the effort is not wasted in the end. Be steadfast and sweet fruits of success will arrive at your doorway :)